The Italian profession has taken a
nosedive as the full effects of the economic downturn hit the
revenues of firms.
This year’s International Accounting Bulletin
survey reveals market growth of just 3 percent, the worst market
result for Italian firms in at least five years (see chart, right).
This modest growth is also the lowest among any markets this
publication has surveyed over the past 12 months and considerably
less than the 14 percent market increase in revenue for the
2006-2007 financial year.
Five firms experienced a decline in growth,
including the second largest firm PricewaterhouseCoopers Italy
(PwC). Only seven out of the 29 firms, networks and associations
surveyed achieved double-digit revenue growth (turn to pages
PwC’s result reflects the loss of major audit
clients and a cooling down of transactions and IPO activity due to
the credit crunch.
Although mandatory audit work remains stable, firms
have noted that due diligence engagements have dried up.
RSM Italy partner Stefano Bianchi said the
first quarter of 2009 was the worst in the past two years.
“In Italy, we had just 46 transactions with a
value of €2.6 million ($3.4 million). This is compared with 77
transactions worth €21 million in the first quarter of last year,”
DFK Italia executive director PierGiuseppe
Ferri noted a 30 percent reduction in due diligence engagements
compared to the previous financial year.
“We understand this variation is connected to
the reduction of the extraordinary operations like M&A in Italy
as a result of the economic downturn,” he said.
PwC’s business advisory practice generated €83
million in fees in the year to 30 June 2008. This is identical to
the previous year’s result.
PwC’s advisory practice is split into two
streams: performance improvement and business consulting; and
transaction services, which includes due diligence, M&A,
valuations and related work.
“Our second stream, transactions work, is
clearly suffering due to the crisis. There is less work with
private equities and extraordinary operations,” PwC Italy managing
director Pierangelo Schiavi said. “Business consulting is a little
bit different and depends on the industry sector. Financial
services, government and health care are performing well. We have
some problems with our industry clients, which have reduced their
budgets for consulting work. The total amount on an engagement 2-3
years ago could be €400,000 to €500,000 but now it is less.”
PwC helps IPO clients prepare paperwork around
initial listings, including the detailed prospectus. These
activities often involve audit, advisory, tax and legal work.
“IPOs have completely disappeared in the past
12-18 months,” Schiavi explained. “There were about 15-20 IPOs per
year. Of them we were involved in a little bit more than one third,
but now it has gone to zero in Italy. I think the last one was 12
Schiavi says the average range in fees of an
IPO engagement is between €400,000-€800,000.
“We have had some IPOs with amounts clearly
above €1 million. If you perform about 10 or more of this IPO work
in one year you have between €7 million to €10 million revenue
coming from these activities,” he explained.
Although transactions work is dwindling, it is
partly being mitigated by counter-cyclical advisory services such
as forensic accounting, restructuring and business planning.