The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) handed out fines totalling £42.9m before settlement discounts in 2018/19, a near trebling in annual fines from £15.5m in 2017/18. After settlement discounts are taking into account, fines issued in 2019/19 totalled £32m, up from £13.1m in 2017/18.
The FRC also reported far greater use and range of non-financial sanctions, rising from 11 in 2017/18 to 38 in 2018/2019. The FRC has issued its first Annual Enforcement Review which reveals a significant increase in sanctions and settlements overall. The watchdog also said there had been a significant reduction in “legacy” cases, increased use of horizon scanning techniques to identify issues requiring investigation and a 25% in year growth in the Enforcement Division.
The FRC published financial sanctions in relation to nine audit investigations during the year. The total amount of financial sanctions on audit firms (pre-discount for settlement) was £40.6 million. The increase in total financial sanctions is partly due to an increased number of cases being concluded (either following Tribunal proceedings or firms agreeing to settle cases prior to a Tribunal hearing).
KPMG faced the biggest bill over the year with fines before discounts totalling £18.5m (discounted to £15.25m) relating to four audits: Quindell, Ted Baker, Equity Syndicate and Co-operative Bank. The largest single fine of £10m (£6.5m after discount) was imposed on PwC for the BHS audit.
The Review provides a baseline for measuring future enforcement performance as the FRC transitions into the Audit, Reporting and Governance Authority (ARGA) and highlights issues identified in enforcement cases and actions taken to address them.
The FRC’s Executive Counsel Elizabeth Barrett the said: “The clarity and accuracy of financial reporting is of critical importance to us all. The significant increase in the number, range and severity of sanctions sends a clear message that where behaviour falls short of what is required, we will hold those responsible to account.
“Improved behaviour by those we regulate requires recognition that where failures occur their root causes must be identified, effectively addressed and reported to us. Where such co-operation occurs due credit will be given; where it does not, consequences will be severe.”