• Register
Return to: Home > News > Brexit economic cost is “gobbledygook” says an ICAEW member and Tory MP

Brexit economic cost is “gobbledygook” says an ICAEW member and Tory MP

Peter Bone, a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) and a Tory MP told the MailOnline that the UK Treasury's economic analysis addressing a potential Brexit can be called "gobbledygook".

On 18 April the Treasury published a study called The long-term economic impact of EU membership and the alternatives.

In this study the Treasury argues that a Brexit will have a negative impact on the national economy, which could make UK households £4,300 ($6,107) worse off per year.

The Treasury's analysis considered three Brexit scenarios for the next 15 years.

First, a scenario whereby the UK would be a member of the European Economic Area, following the model of Norway. In this case the annual loss of GDP per household would be £2,600.

Second, a scenario in which EU membership is replaced by a negotiated bilateral agreement, on the same model as the agreements in place between the EU and Switzerland, Turkey or Canada. The cost of leaving the EU in this case would be £4,300.

In the third scenario, the UK relationship with the EU is exclusively based upon a World Trade Organisation (WTO) membership, like Russia or Brazil. The cost for UK households yearly is in this case £5,200.

All in all, after 15 years the UK GDP would be between 5.4% and 9.5% lower.

Bone told the MailOnline: "I've studied the document closely and we have an accountancy term for the document: it's called gobbledygook."

"You can make any assumption about the future and produce any result you want and producing complicated formulas and saying this looks very important and must be right because the Government says so and isn't this complicated - that's what they're relying on, there's just no basis for it."

Bone continued: "There's absolutely no basis and it's completely foundless but because they say it over and over again as if it's a fact, people start to believe it and that's what this Project Fear is about."

A spokesperson for ICAEW said the institute would not comment on the views that its members hold.

Asked whether ICAEW has officially taken a stand on the referendum, the spokesperson said: "As an organisation ICAEW is taking a neutral position on the EU Referendum. We will however seek to inform the discussion so that our members, as well as the wider electorate, can make an informed choice."


Top Content

    France: professionalising advisory in times of transformation

    Six months into Macron’s presidency and as reforms starts to filter through, what are the main considerations for the accountancy profession? Vincent Huck reports from the French Institute for Accountants’ (Ordre des Experts-Comptables – OEC) annual congress

    read more

    France’s next revolution: boosting the economy, with advisory backing

    As French minister for the economy and finance, Bruno Le Maire took the stage at the final plenary session of the 72nd congress of the French Institute of Chartered Accountants (Ordre des Experts-Comptables) in Lille, he faced a somewhat hostile audience who had booed government initiatives during previous speeches. But the well-prepared minister told the French profession what it wanted to hear and left with a standing ovation. Whether the government will deliver what he promises remains to be seen. Vincent Huck reports

    read more

    Editor's letter: Nine seconds to make or break

    Time is relative. When Usain Bolt runs 100 metres in a little over nine seconds, time flies and feels like a fleeting instant of dream. But, when six professionals sitting on a panel meet a question with deafening silence for nine seconds, then time painfully drags on in embarrassment.

    read more

    Digital disruption: Do you know your blockchain and AI?

    Digital disruption and its implications for accountancy firms was the topic of a panel discussion chaired by editor Vincent Huck at the BKR International annual conference held in London in October. Here are some of the highlights

    read more
Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy. In the latest update it explains what cookies are and how we use them on our site. To learn more about cookies and their benefits, please view our privacy policy. Please be aware that parts of this site will not function correctly if you disable cookies. By continuing to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy unless you have disabled them.