• Register
Return to: Home > Comments > Editor's letter: In praise of regulatory courage

Editor's letter: In praise of regulatory courage

At International Accounting Bulletin we do admit to a preference for the underdog, but regardless of where one stands on mandatory audit firm rotation, one can only admire the determination and persistence of the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors (IRBA), the South African audit regulator.

This publication and our sister publication The Accountant have followed, with varying degrees of assiduity, IRBA’s quest for better and stronger regulation in South Africa since 2013, when its CEO, Bernard Agulhas, visited London and the UK Financial Reporting Council looking for inspiration.

As the reform comes closer, which will make IRBA the regulator for the whole of the profession and introduce new regulatory requirements such as mandatory audit firm rotation, pressure is mounting on IRBA. As Stephanie Wix reports, IRBA has few friends and supporters within the profession.

We will not pretend here to know what is best. And maybe there is insufficient evidence to show that firm rotation does much for raising quality and competition, as has been argued time and time again. Maybe long audit tenures do contribute to building valuable knowledge, which in turn contributes to audit quality.

But in an age where reputations are as volatile as election polls, it is simply not acceptable for an audit firm to be the auditor of the same company for 70 years or more. Let’s be honest. Familiarity where there is money involved does indeed affect independence. But let’s assume for a minute that it doesn’t, still, the perception of independence is as important as independence itself. Moreover, there is no evidence that mandatory firm rotation contributes to a drop in quality. Italy, after all, has been dealing with it for over 40 years.

Finally, there doesn’t seem to be any malice in IRBA’s activities – as has sometimes been suggested off the record – only the recognition that regulators and regulated entities don’t see the issues at hand from the same angle, and that, ultimately, regulation should steer accounting firms towards respecting their public interest obligations.

The regulatory changes are not yet in place, and the current political and economic situation in South Africa might mean further delays, but hopefully IRBA will be able to maintain its course in the face of adversity, as it has been doing remarkably for the last few years.

Top Content

    Integration and resilience: South of the border

    The ripple effects of the Trump election, the fall in commodity prices, a political crisis in Venezuela, the peace agreement in Colombia, corruption scandals coming out of Brazil and changes in governments have all made for an interesting year in Latin America. But, as the old cliché goes, in all the challenges there are opportunities to grab. Vincent Huck reports

    read more

    KPMG out of south africa?

    KPMG South Africa is in the eye of a storm that could see the end of the Big Four in South Africa, while KPMG International is making desperate attempts to rescue the reputation of its brand both in South Africa and internationally. Vincent Huck reports.

    read more

    Editor's letter: Big four, Big spin

    Tourists roaming the South African national parks generally have stars in their eyes at the mention of the Big Five. In safari terms, the Big Five are the poster boys of tour operators: the lion, the elephant, the Cape buffalo, the leopard and the rhinoceros. The term Big Five originates from hunting; those five animals were considered the hardest to hunt on foot in Africa.

    read more

    Businesses to brave the elements in implementing climate-change disclosures

    As some businesses start to face the challenges of implementing the Taskforce on Climate Related Financial Disclosure (TCFD) final recommendations, accountants position themselves as key advisors in the adoption process, while advocating for industry initiative to make sure that the information reported is comparable at least for companies operating in the same sector.

    read more
Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy. In the latest update it explains what cookies are and how we use them on our site. To learn more about cookies and their benefits, please view our privacy policy. Please be aware that parts of this site will not function correctly if you disable cookies. By continuing to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy unless you have disabled them.