• Register
Return to: Home > announcements > Outcome of disciplinary case in connection with Presbyterian Mutual Society

Outcome of disciplinary case in connection with Presbyterian Mutual Society

Press release by UK FRC

Press release by UK FRC - The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) announces the outcome of the disciplinary case in connection with the conduct of Moore Stephens in Northern Ireland (Moore Stephens (NI) LLP) and David McClean, Audit Engagement Partner, in relation to the audit of the financial statements of Presbyterian Mutual Society (PMS).

In a settlement agreed between the Deputy Executive Counsel to the FRC, Jayne Astley, Moore Stephens (NI) and Mr McClean, and approved by a legal member of the FRC independent Tribunal, Moore Stephens (NI) and Mr McClean admitted that their conduct fell significantly short of the standards reasonably to be expected of a Member Firm and a Member in that they failed to act in accordance with Fundamental Principle (C) 'Professional Competence and Due Care' of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Ireland's (CAI) 2006 Code of Ethics for Members as:

In relation to year ends 2007 and 2008, they failed to obtain an adequate general understanding of the legal and regulatory environment in which PMS operated for the purposes of the audit and, failed adequately to test the assumption on the part of PMS's Board and management that it was complying with its own rules and with applicable legislation and regulation and failed to apply professional scepticism and to obtain sufficient audit evidence to corroborate assurances and representations provided by management (including in particular by recognising or acting upon the need to consider or obtain specialist legal advice);
During the 2008 audit, they failed adequately to test management's assertions that the inadequacy of the liquidity levels at the 2008 year end would be remedied and had insufficient evidence to conclude that the going concern assumption was appropriate and that PMS's lack of liquidity had no impact on the audit opinion.
The parties agreed the following terms of settlement:
Moore Stephens received a fine of £200,000, discounted for settlement to £140,000 and a Reprimand.
Mr McClean received a fine of £29,000, discounted for settlement to £20,000 and a Reprimand.

The amount of the agreed fines took account of the fact that Moore Stephens (NI) LLP is a legally distinct and economically separate entity from Moore Stephens UK Limited and Moore Stephens International Limited.

Top Content

    Blockchain and the Big Four: does it deserve all the hype?

    Although still in its infancy, blockchain is one of the most talked-about technologies of 2018. Will the blockchain bubble burst, or will it live up to its reputation as the ‘new internet’? Eleanor Jerome investigates

    read more

    Malaysia: Ready to show its strength

    Recent changes have enhanced the quality of audit reports in Malaysia, giving the profession a welcome opportunity to demonstrate its value to clients. Paul Golden reports

    read more

    China: Regulating the Chinese dragon

    Harsh regulatory actions and looming US trade wars have been dampening expectations in a Chinese market still full of potential, finds Jonathan Minter

    read more

    Indigenous Australians: New checks and balances

    With fewer than 40 known qualified Indigenous Australian accountants, Jonathan Minter speaks to Shelley Cable from PwC Australia about how increasing this number is an important part of improving the financial literacy of Indigenous communities

    read more
Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy. In the latest update it explains what cookies are and how we use them on our site. To learn more about cookies and their benefits, please view our privacy policy. Please be aware that parts of this site will not function correctly if you disable cookies. By continuing to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy unless you have disabled them.