• Register
Return to: Home > News > Financial Results > PCAOB fines Deloitte Canada for lack of independence

PCAOB fines Deloitte Canada for lack of independence

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) has fined Deloitte Canada $350,000 for failing to maintain its independence during three consecutive audits of Canada-based gold mining company Banro Corporation.

The PCAOB found Deloitte’s independence was impaired during its 2012, 2013 and 2014 audits of Banro because of technical reports that were issued by a South African mine-consulting company, Venmyn Deloitte, which was an affiliate of Deloitte Canada.

In its 2013 and 2014 technical mining reports and media releases, Venmyn Deloitte acknowledged responsibility for Certain Banro gold resources and reserve estimates. The PCAOB found this impaired Deloitte Canada’s independence because both Deloitte Canada and Banro were seen to have a mutual interest in Banro’s estimates being proved correct.

PCAOB’s acting director of enforcement and investigations Mark Adler said: “Deloitte Canada was in essence auditing its own work during the 2012 audit of Banro by relying on Venmyn’s valuation of Banro’s mining assets, in clear violation of independence rules.

“This case also emphasises the need for auditors to consider not only the types of non-audit services provided to clients, but also the impact of public statements made to investors when providing those services.”

Venmyn Deloitte, formerly known as Venmyn Rand, became an associated entity of the firm when it was acquired by Deloitte South Africa in 2012. Thereafter, Venmyn Deloitte was considered part of Deloitte Canada for purposes of the auditor independence rules of the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Deloitte Canada did not admit or deny the findings of the PCAOB but agreed to be censured and to undertake a review of its independence policies and procedures and its independence training. The firm will also have to report to the PCAOB the results of its reviews and any changes made.

Deloitte Canada said in a statement: "The matter had no impact on the client’s financial statements or the audit opinions on those financial statements. Deloitte Canada made judgments at the time on the application of the independence rules. The PCAOB has concluded that these judgments were not consistent with the independence rules. Deloitte Canada accepts that conclusion."

Top Content

    South Africa: sensing new opportunities

    It has been an interesting couple of years for the profession in South Africa. A number of high-profile scandals have brought the profession and the role of auditors into sharp public focus, brewing a distrust towards accountants and a large expectations gap. Joe Pickard reports.

    read more

    Ghana: a quest for consistency

    Ghana’s current economic profile would suggest a fertile landscape for purveyors of accounting services. But inconsistent approaches to compliance and application of standards – coupled with problems in the banking sector and consequent liquidity constraints – have created a challenging environment. Paul Golden writes.

    read more

    Drone technology: audit takes to the skies

    The movement towards a digitised era has already impacted the auditing profession in a number of ways, from blockchain to artificial intelligence. Now firms are taking to sky and using drone technology in their audits. Mishelle Thurai speaks to Big Four firms to find out more.

    read more

    SBC: a new alliance joins the market

    Jonathan Minter speaks to Paul Tutin, chair of founding firm Streets Chartered Accountants, about why the business and its European partners took the decision to launch their own association.

    read more
Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy. In the latest update it explains what cookies are and how we use them on our site. To learn more about cookies and their benefits, please view our privacy policy. Please be aware that parts of this site will not function correctly if you disable cookies. By continuing to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy unless you have disabled them.